PDA

View Full Version : Are you ready for some football (which owns more?)



Spectre
Oct-02-2004, 04:33 PM
In Canada, unbeknownst to many Americans, we play our own special brand of football. Same basic game, but the rules are a little different. I decided to list the key differences.

League

The NFL is a 32 team league. Each plays 16 games, and they compete for the Super Bowl.

The CFL is a 9 team league. Each plays 18 games, and they compete for the Grey Cup.

Field

The American field is 100 yards long, 53.3 yards wide, and has 10 yard long endzones. The uprights are at the back of the endzone.

The Canadian field is 110 yards long, 65 yards wide, and has 20 yard long endzones. The uprights are at the front of the endzone.

Players

Americans have 11 players on the field at once.

Canadians have 12 players on the field at once.

Downs

Americans have 4 downs to go 10 yards for a first down.

Canadians have 3 downs to go 10 yard for a first down.

Punting/Kicking

In America, if a kick or punt either sails through the endzone, or the returner takes a knee in the endzone, it results in a touchback. The ball is spotted at the returning team's 20. If the returner so desires, he can call for a Fair Catch. If he catches the ball on an FC, he has not allowed to advance, his team gets the ball where he catches it. If he gets hit after calling for an FC, it's a penalty called Fair Catch Interference.

In Canada, if a kick or punt either sails through the endzone, or the returner takes a knee in the endzone, it results in a single. The kicking team receives a single point, and the ball is spotted at the returning team's 35. The returner is given a 5 yard cushion around him before he touches the ball. If a player on the kicking team is within 5 yards of the returner on any side when he picks up or catches the ball, they will get a penalty called No Yards.

Field Goals

In America, a missed field goal can be run back if it is caught in the air. Once it touches the ground, it's a dead ball. After a marked field goal, the team who scored kicks off the ball.

In Canada, a missed field goal is a live ball. Teams will always send one guy deep to field the kick if it's short or wide. The same rule for singles applies as on punts and kickoffs. After a marked field goal, the defense can either receive a kick, or have their offense start on their own 35.

Players

In America, the offense can use any combination of 5; tight ends, halfbacks, fullbacks, and wide receivers. A standard defense is 4 down linemen, 3 linebackers, 2 cornerbacks, 1 strong safety, and one free safety.

In Canada, the offense can use any combination of 6; tight ends, tailbacks (the equivalent of the U.S halfback,) fullbacks, wide receivers, and slot backs (a running back/receiver who lines up about 5 yards outside the offensive line, behind the line of scrimmage.) A standard defense is 4 down linemen, 3 linebackers, 2 cornerbacks, 2 halfbacks (combinations of linebackers and DBs. Generally cover interior receivers.) and 1 safety.

Clock

In America, the game consists of 2 halves, divided up as 4 15 minute quarters. With two minutes left in each half, the clock stops, which is known as the "Two Minute Warning." After the two minute warning, coaches cannot use challenges, they are rather called in from the booth. The play clock is 40 seconds, and 25 seconds after a penalty or change of possesion.

In Canada, the game consists of 2 halves, divided up as 4 15 minute quarters. With three minutes left in each half, the clock stops. Inside of three minutes, the clock stops after every play, and does not start again until the offense is back at the line of scrimmage and the referee blows his whistle. As such, the last three minutes of a Canadian half can take a while. The play clock is 20 seconds.

In both nations, the clock stops after a player runs out of bounds, after an incomplete pass, or on a penalty, and teams have 3 timeouts per half.

Season

In America, the season starts the second week of September. The playoffs start in January, and the Super Bowl is the last week of January. The feature games are played on American Thanksgiving Day. Detroit and Dallas always play on Thanksgiving.

In Canada, the season starts on the third week of June. The playoffs start in November, and the Grey Cup is the third week of November. The feature games are played on Labour Day. The Edmonton Eskimos always visit the Calgary Stampeders, and the Toronto Argonauts always visit the Hamilton Tiger-Cats for the Labour Day Classic.

Grassroots

In both nations, players can start at a very young age, playing Pop Warner in America, and Peewee/Bantam in Canada. Any high school worth it's salt in either nation has a football team, and they compete for State Championships in America, and Provincial Championships in Canada. Most big city schools in Canada are content winning City Championships, and consider Provincials to be a bonus. After high school, players can compete in the NCAA, or in CIS (Canadian Intercollegiate Sport.) CIS teams fight for the Vanier Cup. After that, there are junior leagues in both nations. Many American college players will come to play in the CFL if they are not yet good enough for the NFL.

CarolinaThunder
Oct-02-2004, 04:39 PM
i like american footballs setup better.
E-A-G-L-E-S!!!!!!!:P

Crossfire
Oct-02-2004, 06:23 PM
Do you have college team television coverage in Canada? College football is almost as big, if not as big as professional here in the States.

Spectre
Oct-02-2004, 06:53 PM
Do you have college team television coverage in Canada? College football is almost as big, if not as big as professional here in the States.
We sure do. Especially the Vanier Cup, which is played at the Toronto Skydome in front of about 30 000 people, and seen coast to coast.

Mosquito
Oct-02-2004, 11:42 PM
I prefer rugby.

PWNAGE
Oct-05-2004, 09:20 PM
i like american footballs setup better.
E-A-G-L-E-S!!!!!!!:P
heh heh philly represent

erewgjnrwsgbi
Oct-05-2004, 09:55 PM
I prefer rugby. league..

You're so right!

Leftover_Salmon
Oct-05-2004, 10:49 PM
We sure do. Especially the Vanier Cup, which is played at the Toronto Skydome in front of about 30 000 people, and seen coast to coast.You must be joking...I've barely noticed the games being shown on TSN.

The CFL and CIAU are third-rate football leagues.

NFL is where it's at.

Plus, rouges are gay--a team can just kick a line drive punt in a tied-game situation and still win.

Spectre
Oct-05-2004, 11:17 PM
You must be joking...I've barely noticed the games being shown on TSN.

The CFL and CIAU are third-rate football leagues.

NFL is where it's at.

Plus, rouges are gay--a team can just kick a line drive punt in a tied-game situation and still win.
Well, maybe you should pull your head out of your ass. Because if you bother turning on TSN, every Saturday, they show CIS games. And pretty much every CFL game is broadcast either on TSN or CBC.

I know that Quebecers are bred to hate Canadian institutions, but I'm sick of hearing your anti-Canada bullshit.

Leftover_Salmon
Oct-05-2004, 11:32 PM
Well, maybe you should pull your head out of your ass. Because if you bother turning on TSN, every Saturday, they show CIS games. And pretty much every CFL game is broadcast either on TSN or CBC.

I know that Quebecers are bred to hate Canadian institutions, but I'm sick of hearing your anti-Canada bullshit.It's not "anti-Canada..."

The CFL is a third-rate league...It is below the NFL, maybe slightly below with the NCAA, and about equal with NFL Europe.

You can't argue the talent is, well, non-existent.

And you can't argue that the rouge is a stupid concept.

There are plenty of things I love about Canada--but I'm not going to blindly call the CFL one of them, just because it is the Canadian counterpart to the NFL.

Yes, and as a totally English Jew growing up in the MOST Liberal (as in the party) riding in Canada, I was bred to hate Canada...:rolleyes:

Spectre
Oct-05-2004, 11:36 PM
It's not "anti-Canada..."

The CFL is a third-rate league...It is below the NFL, maybe slightly below with the NCAA, and about equal with NFL Europe.

You can't argue the talent is, well, non-existent.

And you can't argue that the rouge is a stupid concept.

There are plenty of things I love about Canada--but I'm not going to blindly call the CFL one of them, just because it is the Canadian counterpart to the NFL.

Yes, and as a totally English Jew growing up in the MOST Liberal (as in the party) riding in Canada, I was bred to hate Canada...:rolleyes:
Singles are a great concept. They reward more powerful kickers, and it encourages runbacks on kicks because the returner has something to lose by taking a knee.

And the CFL's talent is not non-existant. There are plenty of talented players, you just have to watch a game.

Oh, and I know that minorities love to brag, but your Judaism means nothing to me, and is not relevant to this conversation. Don't try to make this about race.

Leftover_Salmon
Oct-05-2004, 11:56 PM
Singles are a great concept. They reward more powerful kickers, and it encourages runbacks on kicks because the returner has something to lose by taking a knee.

And the CFL's talent is not non-existant. There are plenty of talented players, you just have to watch a game.

Oh, and I know that minorities love to brag, but your Judaism means nothing to me, and is not relevant to this conversation. Don't try to make this about race.It's not about race--I was simply making the point that given my anglophone, anti-Bloc environment, I am not bred to hate Canada.

Talented players? Maybe by schoolyard standards, but most of these guys never even played D1 football.

Singles reward powerful kickers? Once again, it is not hard to line drive a 50+ yard punt. If you think a tie-game should be decided by a punt, well...

And CFL rules make the game easier for the players.

Y4nk5n3t5
Oct-06-2004, 07:00 PM
I saw some stuff on the CFL when I was in Canada, it just didn't look as interesting. And with nine teams over 18 games, that is too many games for so few teams. The NFL is better.

novaz04
Oct-08-2004, 05:17 AM
AFL for me! League is good too.