PDA

View Full Version : Cockfighting ban considered by New Mexico



optid
Feb-27-2007, 06:55 AM
Cockfighting is an organized fight between two roosters presented for its entertainment value. The roosters are fitted with spurs or blades on their legs, placed in a ring or pit, and fight until at least one of them is severely hurt or killed.

This practice is now banned in 48 states, and New Mexico may become the 49th to prohibit it. A bill in the state legislature has cleared its first hurdle. If it passes both houses, Gov. Bill Richardson has promised to sign it.

The Santa Fe New Mexican (http://www.freenewmexican.com/news/57543.html) published this Associated Press story about it on its site.


2007 Legislature: Cockfighters' pleas fail to sway vote

By DEBORAH BAKER | Associated Press
February 25, 2007

Ban on sport has only one more stop before it reaches the full House

A ban on cockfighting in New Mexico cleared a House committee on Saturday, leaving one more stop before it would reach the full House for a vote.

The House Agriculture and Water Resources Committee voted 6-1 to pass the bill along to its next stop, the Judiciary Committee.

The measure outlaws a practice that supporters insist is part of New Mexico tradition and that opponents call a bloodsport.

New Mexico is one of only two states where cockfighting is legal. The other is Louisiana.

"The entire nation has its eyes on New Mexico right now to see if this Legislature has the political courage to ban cockfighting," said the bill's sponsor, Sen. Mary Jane Garcia.

Cockfighters made emotional pleas to the committee to kill the bill.

"By passing this ban, you rob us of our identity, our tradition," said Luis Sevilla of La Union, his voice cracking.

Sevilla said he is a graduate of New Mexico State University in electrical engineering who decided to stay in Southern New Mexico to work for two reasons: family and cockfighting.

"New Mexico is one of the only states to respect our right to practice our tradition," Sevilla said.

Garcia disputed the argument that cockfighting is part of a Hispanic heritage.

"I know about being Hispanic in a rural community," said Garcia, a Democrat from the tiny Southern New Mexico village of Doņa Ana. "Cockfighting has never been part of my culture and my community."

The ban's supporters said cockfights are venues for illegal gambling and underage drinking.

Bernalillo County Sheriff Darren White called cockfighting "a brutal act" and urged passage of a statewide ban.

"This is not about culture. This is not about urban versus rural. ... This is animal cruelty," White said.

The proposed ban has been around for more than two decades, but it picked up steam this year with endorsements from Gov. Bill Richardson and the New Mexico Conference of Catholic Bishops.

Opponents also include Attorney General Gary King, who "believes from a legal standpoint and policy standpoint we should not allow illegal gambling and extreme animal cruelty to go unrestricted and unpunished," Assistant Attorney General David Thomson told the committee.

Jack Cairnes, a former Washington state legislator who now lives in Hobbs, told lawmakers that cockfighting is "a wholesome family hobby."

He said 95 percent of cockfighters are Hispanic and a ban is "clearly racist."

Jim Nance of Socorro County said a ban on cockfighting would pave the way for attempts to ban hunting, roping, fishing and cattle-branding.

It's part of an agenda of animal-rights activists who want "a meatless, petless society where animals are equal to humans," he said.
"It's about criminalizing time-honored traditions. It isn't about chickens," Nance said.

The bill would make it illegal to participate in a cockfight. A first offense would be a petty misdemeanor, a second offense a misdemeanor, and a third or subsequent offense would be a fourth-degree felony.

Voting to pass the bill along without a recommendation were Chairman Andy Nunez, D-Hatch, and Reps. Ray Begaye, D-Shiprock; Joseph Cervantes, D-Las Cruces; Jimmie Hall, R-Albuquerque; Dona Irwin, D-Deming; and Larry Larranaga, R-Albuquerque.

Voting no was Don Tripp, R-Socorro.

Dolphus Raymond
Feb-27-2007, 04:54 PM
This passed in Oklahoma semi-recently, and I can't imagine it wouldn't in New Mexico too. A bunch of counties did fail it, though.

Cruel, horrible sport.

Chronic Town
Feb-27-2007, 11:02 PM
it wasn't before? that's kind of shocking

*Nick*
Feb-27-2007, 11:47 PM
Who the hell enjoys watching that kind of crap? Get a life, and leave the animals alone!

Berserker
Feb-28-2007, 12:41 AM
Who the hell enjoys watching that kind of crap? Get a life, and leave the animals alone!Yeah, I find it really sick. I thought it was banned throughout the whole United States, learn something new every day.

Shangri-la
Feb-28-2007, 01:09 AM
I think its rather disgusting it hasnt been banned already. Its also surprising PETA hasnt been crying foul all these years. It is a rather barbaric practice...

Oh and as I interpret it PETA- People Eating Tasty Animals...

optid
Feb-28-2007, 01:15 AM
Yeah, I find it really sick. I thought it was banned throughout the whole United StatesWhen New Mexico finally enacts the ban, it will still be legal in one state -- Louisiana.

Jorge
Feb-28-2007, 10:08 AM
Racist my ass.

This is a great bill to civilize those who still play it. I'm happy that Bill Richardson is going to sign it. :)

Berserker
Mar-02-2007, 12:41 AM
Oh and as I interpret it PETA- People Eating Tasty Animals...That's original:roll:...:P

alexP
Mar-02-2007, 11:30 AM
You know this was banned about 200 years ago in the UK?

Berserker
Mar-02-2007, 11:16 PM
You know this was banned about 200 years ago in the UK?Thank you so much for that concise bit of information, we all appreciate it.

hehe
Mar-03-2007, 12:22 AM
It's disgraceful that anybody could find entertainment out of forcing animals in a pit to kill each other. It's flat-out inhumane. At least New Mexico is taking steps to ban this...Louisiana on the other hand needs to ban it now.

What is also disturbing is how some people are playing the race card here by saying that banning cockfights is racist because 95% of cockfights are done by Hispanics. I personally despise racism, but this is no racism. If it had been 95% white people, the ban would be just as good in my eyes. Animal cruelty knows no racel; it's wrong no matter who does it. It just so happens to be in this case that 95% of the people doing it are of a certain race. And everyone--people of all races--involved in cockfighting ought to stop immediately.

optid
Mar-03-2007, 12:48 AM
What is also disturbing is how some people are playing the race card here by saying that banning cockfights is racist because 95% of cockfights are done by Hispanics.Nobody takes those charges seriously.

The governor of New Mexico is Hispanic. He supports the bill and has said he will sign it when it lands on his desk.

hehe
Mar-03-2007, 12:53 AM
Nobody takes those charges seriously.

The governor of New Mexico is Hispanic. He supports the bill and has said he will sign it when it lands on his desk.

Thankfully, you're right in that nobody takes those seriously. But the fact that somebody would even make such allegations as racism for banning cockfighting annoys me.

Stewie
Mar-03-2007, 10:28 AM
I don't like the bill. As far as I'm concerned, people have the right to stage cockfights if they so choose.

bloo
Mar-10-2007, 12:18 PM
ugg that sounds horrible